An Ungentlemanly Response: DE Falklands ISOT
- jemhouston
- Posts: 6595
- Joined: Fri Nov 18, 2022 12:38 am
Re: An Ungentlemanly Response: DE Falklands ISOT
removed
Last edited by jemhouston on Thu Nov 19, 2026 11:22 pm, edited 1 time in total.
- jemhouston
- Posts: 6595
- Joined: Fri Nov 18, 2022 12:38 am
Re: An Ungentlemanly Response: DE Falklands ISOT
If it's a fair fight, you're doing something wrong.
-
Simon Darkshade
- Posts: 2189
- Joined: Thu Nov 17, 2022 10:55 am
Re: An Ungentlemanly Response: DE Falklands ISOT
This is going to be nowhere near a fair fight. The two analogous situations are the 1987 Loughall Ambush, where all 8 IRA men were killed whilst trying to attack an RUC post with a digger bomb; and the Road of Death in 1991 if pictures hadn’t been shown to the media.
It can be said that the Argentine invasion is in the realms of a planned armed robbery and conspiracy to commit mass murder, given how Moody Brook barracks was to be attacked/was attacked in our time, being raked with machine gunfire and white phosphorus grenades with the intent of massacring the Royal Marines in their beds.
Whilst an argument can be made that the individual Argentine soldiers, sailors and marines deserve some measure of individual mercy, that can’t be extended to the commanders, planners or willing officers, and in any event, aircraft, shells and missiles cannot take a surrender. The ungentlemanly response is one that isn’t coloured by the same niceties, restrictions and lip service seen in our April-June 1982.
Blackadder (and Fraser, who is yet to appear on ‘screen’ ) is following orders to ensure that the threat is utterly removed, on the thinking (whether it be erroneous or not) that the Argentines got off softly and never dropped their claims to the islands; something different will be forced down their throats here.
This isn’t going to be a thrilling, plucky or heroic story of unlikely resistance lead by a few unlikely, plucky and heroic vintage tanks, nor a defence of a mission station against overwhelming odds until the cavalry can arrive, but something profoundly punitive and Roman.
It can be said that the Argentine invasion is in the realms of a planned armed robbery and conspiracy to commit mass murder, given how Moody Brook barracks was to be attacked/was attacked in our time, being raked with machine gunfire and white phosphorus grenades with the intent of massacring the Royal Marines in their beds.
Whilst an argument can be made that the individual Argentine soldiers, sailors and marines deserve some measure of individual mercy, that can’t be extended to the commanders, planners or willing officers, and in any event, aircraft, shells and missiles cannot take a surrender. The ungentlemanly response is one that isn’t coloured by the same niceties, restrictions and lip service seen in our April-June 1982.
Blackadder (and Fraser, who is yet to appear on ‘screen’ ) is following orders to ensure that the threat is utterly removed, on the thinking (whether it be erroneous or not) that the Argentines got off softly and never dropped their claims to the islands; something different will be forced down their throats here.
This isn’t going to be a thrilling, plucky or heroic story of unlikely resistance lead by a few unlikely, plucky and heroic vintage tanks, nor a defence of a mission station against overwhelming odds until the cavalry can arrive, but something profoundly punitive and Roman.
-
Paul Nuttall
- Posts: 944
- Joined: Thu Nov 17, 2022 5:19 pm
Re: An Ungentlemanly Response: DE Falklands ISOT
Simon Darkshade wrote: ↑Fri Nov 20, 2026 1:58 am This is going to be nowhere near a fair fight. The two analogous situations are the 1987 Loughall Ambush, where all 8 IRA men were killed whilst trying to attack an RUC post with a digger bomb; and the Road of Death in 1991 if pictures hadn’t been shown to the media.
It can be said that the Argentine invasion is in the realms of a planned armed robbery and conspiracy to commit mass murder, given how Moody Brook barracks was to be attacked/was attacked in our time, being raked with machine gunfire and white phosphorus grenades with the intent of massacring the Royal Marines in their beds.
Whilst an argument can be made that the individual Argentine soldiers, sailors and marines deserve some measure of individual mercy, that can’t be extended to the commanders, planners or willing officers, and in any event, aircraft, shells and missiles cannot take a surrender. The ungentlemanly response is one that isn’t coloured by the same niceties, restrictions and lip service seen in our April-June 1982.
Blackadder (and Fraser, who is yet to appear on ‘screen’ ) is following orders to ensure that the threat is utterly removed, on the thinking (whether it be erroneous or not) that the Argentines got off softly and never dropped their claims to the islands; something different will be forced down their throats here.
This isn’t going to be a thrilling, plucky or heroic story of unlikely resistance lead by a few unlikely, plucky and heroic vintage tanks, nor a defence of a mission station against overwhelming odds until the cavalry can arrive, but something profoundly punitive and Roman.
More like clubbing baby seals........
-
Simon Darkshade
- Posts: 2189
- Joined: Thu Nov 17, 2022 10:55 am
Re: An Ungentlemanly Response: DE Falklands ISOT
Only a snippet or a 25% preview of Part 4 tonight, as I've an early shift in the morning:
The Gentoo penguins of Bertha's Beach (as the humans would call it, on account of a long-ago wrecked barque, with the actual penguin name being something rather more longwinded and exceptionally descript regarding the quality of fish) had long enjoyed the relative quiet of the area, in addition to its sheltered comforts and decent foodstuffs, and the fact that the strange hooman creatures tended to keep their distance in recent generations. It came then as something of an unpleasant shock to have their afternoon feeding routine disrupted by some enormous and impossibly fast mottled grey and green bird screaming overhead from the new hooman nest inland and heading up into the skies over the ocean, and one pair were quite vocal about their discombobulation.
"Damn crazy fliers! They've utterly no concern about their neighbours, carrying on like that!"
"Oh, come on, Mzewijki - you complain about everything that flies over you. Anyway, who are you going to complain to about it - David Attenborough?"
"You leave David out of this, Gladyz!"
XZ2476, an RAF Avro Arrow Mk.6, had by this time left the penguin domestic dispute far behind and below, and now headed out on its appointed patrol pattern, breaking through Mach 1 and then Mach 2 as it went, levelling off at 65,000ft and slowing down to her super cruising speed. Flight Lieutenant Gavin Fairfax knew that his role here was purely precautionary, flying loops over the southern part of the Falklands as an RNAS Nimrod went up to fix the location of the incoming Argentine fleet. He seemed almost naked, popping up here with only four medium range Skyblades and four short range Firebolts on board, but needs must on what was undoubtedly the strangest day of his life.
Fifteen minutes later, his radioan
"Orion 4, Xanadu. Huntsman 1 has contact. Over."
"Roger, Xanadu. Will maintain station as scheduled, then RTB. Over."
The Nimrod had located what could only be the Argentine fleet 254 nautical miles NNW of Stanley. Based on the speed of the group, which was made up of one rather child-size aircraft carrier, one guided missile destroyer, six smaller destroyers or frigates, one LST, one tanker and one icebreaker, they would be reaching the Falklands some time around 0600. A further guided missile destroyer was out in front 52nm to the south east, and travelling rather faster. The role of the Nimrods would now be to stay out at least 125nm off the two groups and monitor them until such time as a pair of the South Atlantic Fleet's Watchman AEW jets would be in range to take over the shadowing role at 1800. Then it would be time to return to base and prepare for the morrow's action.
After rather hasty deliberation with Colonel Blackadder and Admiral Fraser and his staff, Wing Commander Christopher Wainwright had come out with a rough plan, whereby the land based air would initially take care of the single destroyer, wherever it was headed, then provide a strike against the main Argentine carrier group coming in from the southwest with the remainder of the strike package. The six Hawker-Siddeley Phantom FGR.1s were to be fueled up and equipped with two Sea Eagle anti-ship missiles and two Fairey Blue Cheese rocket bombs apiece, along with a mixture of 3.75" rockets, napalm and 500lb bombs for good measure, whilst the Arrows would utilise their limited air to ground capacity by each carrying a Martel anti-radiation missile to deal with the destroyer's RDF.
The naval air strike would be somewhat more substantive, consisting of a total of 102 aircraft, with 16 de Havilland Vanguard fleet air superiority fighters providing top cover and escort, 16 Phantoms, 16 Buccaneers, 8 Excaliburs, 16 Fireflies and 24 Scimitars providing the strike element and two Watchmen and four Stalker electronic warfare jammers completing the force. It was considered that such a relatively light air package would be sufficient against the Argentine task group, whilst retaining the bulk of the fleet air power for any further contingencies; should it not, then the battleships would be within range to fire with their 24" guns and anti-ship missiles.
.........
The Gentoo penguins of Bertha's Beach (as the humans would call it, on account of a long-ago wrecked barque, with the actual penguin name being something rather more longwinded and exceptionally descript regarding the quality of fish) had long enjoyed the relative quiet of the area, in addition to its sheltered comforts and decent foodstuffs, and the fact that the strange hooman creatures tended to keep their distance in recent generations. It came then as something of an unpleasant shock to have their afternoon feeding routine disrupted by some enormous and impossibly fast mottled grey and green bird screaming overhead from the new hooman nest inland and heading up into the skies over the ocean, and one pair were quite vocal about their discombobulation.
"Damn crazy fliers! They've utterly no concern about their neighbours, carrying on like that!"
"Oh, come on, Mzewijki - you complain about everything that flies over you. Anyway, who are you going to complain to about it - David Attenborough?"
"You leave David out of this, Gladyz!"
XZ2476, an RAF Avro Arrow Mk.6, had by this time left the penguin domestic dispute far behind and below, and now headed out on its appointed patrol pattern, breaking through Mach 1 and then Mach 2 as it went, levelling off at 65,000ft and slowing down to her super cruising speed. Flight Lieutenant Gavin Fairfax knew that his role here was purely precautionary, flying loops over the southern part of the Falklands as an RNAS Nimrod went up to fix the location of the incoming Argentine fleet. He seemed almost naked, popping up here with only four medium range Skyblades and four short range Firebolts on board, but needs must on what was undoubtedly the strangest day of his life.
Fifteen minutes later, his radioan
"Orion 4, Xanadu. Huntsman 1 has contact. Over."
"Roger, Xanadu. Will maintain station as scheduled, then RTB. Over."
The Nimrod had located what could only be the Argentine fleet 254 nautical miles NNW of Stanley. Based on the speed of the group, which was made up of one rather child-size aircraft carrier, one guided missile destroyer, six smaller destroyers or frigates, one LST, one tanker and one icebreaker, they would be reaching the Falklands some time around 0600. A further guided missile destroyer was out in front 52nm to the south east, and travelling rather faster. The role of the Nimrods would now be to stay out at least 125nm off the two groups and monitor them until such time as a pair of the South Atlantic Fleet's Watchman AEW jets would be in range to take over the shadowing role at 1800. Then it would be time to return to base and prepare for the morrow's action.
After rather hasty deliberation with Colonel Blackadder and Admiral Fraser and his staff, Wing Commander Christopher Wainwright had come out with a rough plan, whereby the land based air would initially take care of the single destroyer, wherever it was headed, then provide a strike against the main Argentine carrier group coming in from the southwest with the remainder of the strike package. The six Hawker-Siddeley Phantom FGR.1s were to be fueled up and equipped with two Sea Eagle anti-ship missiles and two Fairey Blue Cheese rocket bombs apiece, along with a mixture of 3.75" rockets, napalm and 500lb bombs for good measure, whilst the Arrows would utilise their limited air to ground capacity by each carrying a Martel anti-radiation missile to deal with the destroyer's RDF.
The naval air strike would be somewhat more substantive, consisting of a total of 102 aircraft, with 16 de Havilland Vanguard fleet air superiority fighters providing top cover and escort, 16 Phantoms, 16 Buccaneers, 8 Excaliburs, 16 Fireflies and 24 Scimitars providing the strike element and two Watchmen and four Stalker electronic warfare jammers completing the force. It was considered that such a relatively light air package would be sufficient against the Argentine task group, whilst retaining the bulk of the fleet air power for any further contingencies; should it not, then the battleships would be within range to fire with their 24" guns and anti-ship missiles.
.........
-
Simon Darkshade
- Posts: 2189
- Joined: Thu Nov 17, 2022 10:55 am
Re: An Ungentlemanly Response: DE Falklands ISOT
Not at all, as I am quite the animal lover.Paul Nuttall wrote: ↑Fri Nov 20, 2026 1:12 pmSimon Darkshade wrote: ↑Fri Nov 20, 2026 1:58 am This is going to be nowhere near a fair fight. The two analogous situations are the 1987 Loughall Ambush, where all 8 IRA men were killed whilst trying to attack an RUC post with a digger bomb; and the Road of Death in 1991 if pictures hadn’t been shown to the media.
It can be said that the Argentine invasion is in the realms of a planned armed robbery and conspiracy to commit mass murder, given how Moody Brook barracks was to be attacked/was attacked in our time, being raked with machine gunfire and white phosphorus grenades with the intent of massacring the Royal Marines in their beds.
Whilst an argument can be made that the individual Argentine soldiers, sailors and marines deserve some measure of individual mercy, that can’t be extended to the commanders, planners or willing officers, and in any event, aircraft, shells and missiles cannot take a surrender. The ungentlemanly response is one that isn’t coloured by the same niceties, restrictions and lip service seen in our April-June 1982.
Blackadder (and Fraser, who is yet to appear on ‘screen’ ) is following orders to ensure that the threat is utterly removed, on the thinking (whether it be erroneous or not) that the Argentines got off softly and never dropped their claims to the islands; something different will be forced down their throats here.
This isn’t going to be a thrilling, plucky or heroic story of unlikely resistance lead by a few unlikely, plucky and heroic vintage tanks, nor a defence of a mission station against overwhelming odds until the cavalry can arrive, but something profoundly punitive and Roman.
More like clubbing baby seals........
This is simply killing enemy humans and destroying enemy stuff, without any negative connotations or associating wannabe fascists with poor baby seals.
It will also make for an interesting scene when the news filters in to Galtieri, as well as to other leaders.
-
Belushi TD
- Posts: 1926
- Joined: Thu Nov 17, 2022 11:20 am
Re: An Ungentlemanly Response: DE Falklands ISOT
Have no fear. There's no need for a defense at all. I was highly amused by the ironic imagery, and sought to mention it in a humorous way.Simon Darkshade wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 3:52 pm
2.) Indeed, I remember it clearly. My little attempt at waxing lyrical in my use of ironic imagery was, in my defence, written in the wee hours of the morning and not accompanied by context adding emoticons with winky smiley faces, due to me dropping my phone in bed and falling asleep for a few hours in the midst of drafting the above post. I'm actually shocked that the darn Safari thing didn't reset itself as is its usual want.
If I recall correctly, you were the one who suggested that I now call him my "descendant". I've gotten a LOT of mileage out of that joke. *grin*
Belushi TD
*edit* Ooooooo!!!! I just noticed that there's some of the 24 inch battleships along.... Question - A 24 inch shell - Wouldn't that just go right through without exploding, a la Yamato vs. Taffy 3? *edit*
-
Simon Darkshade
- Posts: 2189
- Joined: Thu Nov 17, 2022 10:55 am
Re: An Ungentlemanly Response: DE Falklands ISOT
Belushi,
No fear, just the ever present threat of sleep obscuring meaning.usually I’m quite good at sleeping - I can do it with my eyes closed.
Descendant is me. There’s life in the old puppy yet.
The modern British 24” shell comes in various sorts, but what would be used against an unarmoured destroyer is an HE shell with a contact fuse. It is unlikely that, after 80-84 strike planes finish up, that there will be much left of the assorted Argentine ships requiring surface gunfire.
An undertone of the overkill is that the DE planners don’t really know what they are up against, so are working on the basis of what they consider a destroyer or frigate or carrier. To make things more darkly amusing, the DE Type 42 is a 12500t DLG that would require a lot of force to take down, not a cost effective 3500-4000t FFG without any point defence or short range missiles…
No fear, just the ever present threat of sleep obscuring meaning.usually I’m quite good at sleeping - I can do it with my eyes closed.
Descendant is me. There’s life in the old puppy yet.
The modern British 24” shell comes in various sorts, but what would be used against an unarmoured destroyer is an HE shell with a contact fuse. It is unlikely that, after 80-84 strike planes finish up, that there will be much left of the assorted Argentine ships requiring surface gunfire.
An undertone of the overkill is that the DE planners don’t really know what they are up against, so are working on the basis of what they consider a destroyer or frigate or carrier. To make things more darkly amusing, the DE Type 42 is a 12500t DLG that would require a lot of force to take down, not a cost effective 3500-4000t FFG without any point defence or short range missiles…